CS-OA cs-vo Faang

Dissecting Meta’s Profiling Puzzle: An Insight into the Interview Question’s Design

Meta's interview questions are often designed to evaluate a candidate's problem-solving skills, understanding of programming concepts, and attention to detail. The profiling puzzle provided is a prime example of how these elements are integrated into a single challenge. This article will critique the question's structure, complexity, and relevance to real-world programming scenarios, offering insights into its effectiveness as a measure of a potential employee's capabilities.

We are profiling the performance of some app. In order to do that, app is instrumented to log events for beginning and end of each function. An event is a record with three fields: 1. function name 2. timestamp 3. type (begin or end)


foo, 10, b
bar, 20, b
bar, 50, e
foo, 100, e

Given such a log, compute exclusive running time for each function (exclusive time excludes time spent in function's sub-routines).

For above example the expected output is:

foo: 60
bar: 30

The provided problem revolves around computing the exclusive running time of functions within an application. At first glance, the task seems straightforward—calculate the duration that each function takes without considering the time spent on its sub-routines. This is a common requirement in performance profiling, where understanding the time taken by individual components of a system is crucial for optimization.

Upon closer examination, the question's brilliance lies in its simplicity which conceals a test of several competencies. It assesses the candidate's ability to:

  1. Understand the Domain: Profiling is a niche area requiring specific knowledge, and the ability to understand the task at hand is critical.
  2. Handle Data Structures: The candidate must effectively manage and manipulate data, possibly using stacks or other structures to keep track of the functions and their times.
  3. Apply Algorithmic Thinking: The solution requires a logical approach to subtract the time taken by nested functions, which could be seen as an exercise in recursion or stack handling.
  4. Pay Attention to Detail: With the potential for nested functions and overlapping execution times, precision is necessary to avoid miscalculations.
  5. Optimize Solutions: While there may be multiple ways to solve the problem, finding the most efficient solution is key, reflecting a programmer's ability to write performance-sensitive code.

Critically, the question tests a candidate's practical skills rather than theoretical knowledge alone. It's pertinent to a real-world task—optimizing application performance—which is a valuable skill in the industry. This relevance boosts the question's utility as a barometer for a candidate's potential job performance.

However, no question is without its flaws. This puzzle could be criticized for its potential ambiguity regarding the handling of concurrent function calls or recursive functions if they are a part of the scenario, as these details are not explicitly outlined in the brief.

In conclusion, Meta's profiling puzzle serves as an excellent tool for measuring a candidate's practical coding skills, problem-solving ability, and attention to detail. While it stands strong on various fronts, including relevance and complexity, ensuring clarity in its presentation would further solidify its effectiveness. It is a well-rounded question that reflects the type of thinking and expertise a programmer would need on the job, thereby affirming its place in the interview process.

根据需要我们可以提供面试辅助,代面试 等特殊服务,帮您拿到offer



We can provide special services such as interview assistance and proxy interviews as needed to help you secure your offer

Finding a job is not something that can be achieved overnight. If younger students want to have an internship experience in a large company, they need to make sufficient preparations in advance.

【 Go 】 Learn about job search services and comprehensively enhance your job search competitiveness!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *